Allie Dixon
Good Grey
At the end of the day, stripped down after a shower, in the mirror when the white steam clears, I see through myself to black underthings, an impish grin, and an envelope of stolen cash in my hands. And even now, I’m enamored by the neon butterfly swirls of my brain.
“Based on your assessments, you appear to have Bipolar II,” says Dr. Givon. She is crying. I’m not. I cross my legs and say nothing. I only nod and apply more tinted lip balm.
“How do you feel hearing that?” she asks. She dabs her eyes. We just met today, and she is tender as if I’m one of her own and she’s weighted with the motherly burden of breaking my heart.
“I’m not surprised. But I’m wondering why you’re so upset,” I say. I smack my plum lips together.
“Bipolar, when untreated, is a degenerative brain disorder.”
“I’d really like to stop using the word disorder,” I say. I spit these words out, surprised by my own reaction.
“That’s not all,” she says. Her Yiddish accent is hard but melodic. How gently she speaks makes this all feel like a dream.
On my drive home from teaching Psycho all day, I find myself repulsed by how grey the city is. Every building, every car, everybody is rock-salt-slush-stained-grey. There are no faces to meet. All heads are tuck-bundled into coat collars and scarves. All coats are dull-colored and zipped. I hear myself preaching to my class as an echo in my head, all students wide-eyed and actually listening to me yammering about how good grey is. All meaning is in the tension of the grey. We are not black and white. The tension of binary opposites is where we float along. I sound like I know what I’m talking about. But right now, at this stop light as the traffic rushes by in a silverish blur, I am full of shit. I hate the grey.
I’m sitting in a chair in a dark room staring at the scans of my brain, glowing like beautiful bugs, intricate in lines and bright in color. I’m waiting for Dr. Givon to enter. I hear her outside the door, her muffled—mhms, yes, of course, I think that’ll work—encourage me. But I already know what I’m looking at. I sit here pinned in between the two panes of knowing and hope. Either way, I have to get it over with. Class is soon. It’s Hitchcock day in film. Dr. Givon enters and sits beside me. She holds my hand. For a moment, I think I must be dying.
My favorite slide is projected. I see my film students nodding. This is what you can do with film, I tell them, just like in writing. Isn’t it interesting to have a visual medium for your point?
Still shots of Marion Crane are side by side, one of her in a white bra and slip, the other in black after she steals the money. Below it we have the police car, the newspaper that wraps up a bundle of stolen money, all black and white.
“Hitchcock chose to film this in black and white as well,” I say. “Yes, to cut some production costs. But why else might he do this?” I ask.
Someone raises their hand. When their sleeve slides down their arm, I admire a black ink butterfly tattoo on their wrist. It’s delicate, but the lines of it are so sure.
“It’s scarier,” they say.
“It is,” I agree. “Why?”
“You have to imagine the color,” they say.
I raise my eyebrows. I’ve never thought of it this way.
“True. We know blood is red. We all see red being washing down the drain even though it’s blackish on screen. But it’s all made of opposites. Black and white. What we know versus what we see. So what?”
“It’s extra tension,” a few of them say out loud in their own versions, but in unison.
I nod and smack my lips together.
“And that’s where the meaning is. That’s where the good stuff is. All meaning is in the tension of the grey. We are not black and white. The tension of binary opposites is where we float along.”
We continue to talk about Norman Bates’ black and white outfit that echoes a priest collar, if either character is truly good or bad, black or white, and they are frustrated at character complexity. They want it to be easy. Sometimes, I do, too. But their excitement over discovering how much black and white is within the black and white pleases me. Their theories churn out fast.
I’m not thrilled with meeting my new doctor at eight in the morning before work. But it was the only time available for months. I have new insurance now at this new teaching job. I might as well see what I can get covered. The NP comes in, and I feel comforted already. She’s a little older than I am. Something about her is earthy. It’s her thick wavy brown hair in a low bun, I think. She’s calm. Her name is the same as mine. I feel the mirror of the earthiness inside me, but mine is muddy. For some reason, I feel compelled to tell her.
“Let’s start with general history,” she says.
“Can I talk to you first about my head?” I ask.
“Are we talking migraines?”
She wheels closer to me. I smooth my white paper gown over my lap.
“No, I just feel foggy all the time. It’s bad. For the longest time I feel like my brain is wrapped up in cotton or cobweb or something. I can’t clean it.”
She stares at me.
“Do you sleep a lot?” she asks.
“It’s strange. I go through periods of not being able to get off my couch and then periods of never sleeping and doing every project I can ever think of until I collapse.”
She stares at me more.
“What about moods?” she asks.
“Honestly?”
“Yes.”
“I’m either volatile and impatient or pretty euphoric like, on top of the world, euphoric. I’ve been asking about this for a very long time. I refuse to believe this is how people function. The older I get, the worse it gets. I need help.”
I’ve never said I need help before. I feel a hard coal lump forming in my throat. I swallow it down. It hurts.
“So, what I think we should do is send you upstairs to talk to Dr. Givon. You will love her. She is so sweet and so knowledgeable,” says the NP that in another life is me.
I know there’s a lump in her throat, too. It’s what she’s not telling me.
It’s not too late for me to cancel class and go home. I’m so tired. In the parking lot, the campus buildings seem extra gothic. The shadows are darker. The peaks are sharper. The mid-morning sun off the windows is brighter, blinding. All at once, I sigh and start crying so hard that I call it ugly-crying. I have no control over my facial muscles. I can’t inhale all the way. Is this me unraveling? Is this degenerative me? I didn’t expect to be cracked wide open today. All my guts spilled out fire engine red against the black and white shell that was once me. Mixed together, I’m grey. I don’t know this girl behind the wheel. I don’t know if I like her yet. She is the opposite of last week’s me and will be opposite of next week’s. She’s pinned between the panes of knowing and hope. But today is Hitchcock day. I dry my eyes with a used Dunkin’ Donuts napkin crumbled in my cupholder and force-sprout a pair of technicolor wings from my back. They match my brain.
It’s a little early in life for me to be getting my first pap smear. I’m sixteen. But I’ve had my period for over a month. I sit cold and naked on paper that crinkles at a sound-barrier-breaking volume. The gown is cloth and light. I rub my thighs to warm up. The tray of metal tools that will be inside me all look cold.
When the doctor comes in, she makes small talk. She asks me about school as she gloves up, jellies her fingers, and tells me to scootch down.
“What’s your favorite subject?” she asks as if she’s not elbow deep in my cervix.
“I like English. I like film. I think I’d like to teach someday. Being creative helps my moods.”
Today, my brain is wrapped in cobweb. I want to cry and be silent but scream, too. I want help without having to say it, because I can’t.
“Well, moody is normal. It gets worse as you get older. Welcome to womanhood. But what you’re doing, finding outlets, that’s great.”
She wheels away. I hate the cold wet spot between my legs as I get dressed, slipping on my white cotton underwear and bra. The automatic lights turn off, and I wonder if I’m invisible, but feel inexplicably perverse.
I’m fourteen in science class. I like science, but I can’t wait for English next block. I’m looking at a butterfly wing beneath a microscope, feeling for some reason like I want to scream as loud as I can, leap out the window, and run until my lungs explode. The beauty of the wing between two glass panes against its black plate, delicate in lines, certain in neon multicolor, seizes me. I want to cry at it. I wonder if anyone else feels this way. I wonder if anyone else sees the world as a kaleidoscope sometimes, and then other times grey. I know they don’t. But I hope so.
When my science teacher Mrs. Ganshert places her hand on my shoulder and asks what I think, I am surprised at the bull-run force honesty of my words that burst out.
“It’s perfect,” I say. “I can’t believe nature can do this.”
“I know,” she says. “Hang on to that feeling.”
And she squeezes my shoulder as if I’m hers, as if she knows something I don’t.
All I know then is that I want to teach someday, and I hope my students actually listen to me when I tell them how perfect the colors of a butterfly are.

Allie Dixon
Allie Dixon is a writer and artist based in Boston. Her work has appeared in The Threepenny Review, PRISM International, Ruminate, Writer’s Digest, and elsewhere, and her visual artwork has been exhibited across Boston. She is represented by Trident Media Group and is currently at work on her second novel. Alongside her creative work, Allie teaches writing and media at Emmanuel College and writes for New England Primate Conservancy, where she gets to bring together her love of writing, animals, and the natural world.