Jamie Li
The Scholastic Book Thief

In my second-grade school portrait, I’m wearing my favorite turtleneck from Walmart. Lopsided bangs cut across my forehead. Baby teeth are missing, but I’m grinning anyway. Given my pleasant expression, nobody would’ve guessed that this eight-year-old girl was an expert thief of paperbacks, floofy pens, and tasseled bookmarks.
Anyone who attended an American school from the ’80s onward may remember the Scholastic Book Fair. Students anticipate it like a major holiday, and adults remember it with a rosy fondness. This weeklong literary bonanza helps children discover the joys of reading by way of another beloved American pastime: shopping. As a recent immigrant and mid-year transfer student at Beacon Hill Elementary, I knew none of this. All I knew was that my fobbish hand-me-downs and afternoon ESL classes couldn’t have made me more conspicuous. I just wanted to fit in—and fast.
The book fair took place inside our school library. Gleaming metal bookshelves filled with Scholastic’s new releases lined the library’s interior. In the center stood tables of stuff tangentially related to reading: fragrant erasers that resembled tiny fruit, novelty keychains, safari-themed notebooks.
In class, one week before the fair, Mrs. Keith passed out pre-order catalogs. An anticipatory buzz swept across the room. Kids oohed and aahed over the latest titles and chattered about what they planned to order. I didn’t really know what to expect, but I let myself feel giddy too.
At home, I pored over each saturated page, inhaling its pulpy scent. I meticulously read the blurbs of every item and circled my selections. On the back, I totaled my order. Twenty-two dollars and seven cents. Practically a fortune! I considered asking my parents for money even though which crispy paperback I wanted (never mind a hardcover) definitely did not figure into the household budget. Their priorities were adding milk to stretch our canned chowder or snatching up more overtime shifts. Showing them the catalog was a mistake. I promptly got an earful about how my lust for shiny merchandise would plunge us into financial ruin. How dare I even think about buying a bookmark when any of the crumpled receipts on our kitchen counter would do. When I had access to a whole library at school. Surely, they hissed, they were not raising their daughter to be this frivolous.
While thumbing through the catalog did give me a sense of participating in something collective and joyful, for me, it was all pretend. Each tally mark was a taunting reminder of what I couldn’t have. And because my parents framed their stinginess—something I had no control over—as a barbed personal attack, I decided to take schoolyard matters into my own hands, and it’d be none of their business.
When pre-orders arrived, we walked into class to see shrink-wrapped bundles atop each other’s desks. Mrs. Keith stood by, a placid smile on her face, as students raced inside—shrieking, eyes wide—to tear into their packages. Kids who ordered the same books bonded instantly, a new social currency forming within seconds. The spectacle put our economic statuses on full display. Who ordered the entire boxed set of Magic Tree House? Who got a measly little notepad? Who had received nothing at all? I remember having the sole barren desktop. But I can’t be sure because we poor kids were doing a performance of our own: one of indifference, doing our best to be invisible in the commotion because inviting pity was worse than being ignored.
The week of the actual book fair presented me with another shot at inclusion. Buying anything was out of the question, so petty crime it was. Blinded by a searing need to assimilate and without parents helicoptering over my life, I didn’t necessarily see stealing as wrong. If anything, it felt fair. Why did the other Chinese girl with immigrant parents have a thirty-pack of gel pens when I only had dollar-store BIC ones? Besides, Scholastic clearly had plenty of inventory, so what was one or two books missing from their shelves? It was a victimless crime!
My shoplifting strategy was simple: be stealthy and swift. Based on my recess eavesdropping, Ella Enchanted was the book to read. Entering the library, I spotted the cover, with its graceful portrait of the titular Ella smirking back at me, practically daring me to lift the book. I scooped it up. Not too eagerly, but more nonchalant—as if I were putting toys away. Circling the shelves, I plucked out a few decoy books as I kept my eyes trained on the two librarians by the register. I knelt down, pretending to browse the lower shelves. Out of view, I slid the book down my waistband, crimping my right arm over my side to hold it in place. I left my pile of decoy books on a nearby table; that way, if a librarian asked where I put the books, I could point to them on my way out. And just as quietly as I had entered, I slipped out of the library while my heart thudded against my ribcage. As the week went on, I returned for more. I got familiar with the lay of the land: which corners shielded me from view, when the lunchtime foot traffic dwindled, and which librarians seemed most distracted. When the coast was clear, I slid pens up my shirt sleeve, bookmarks into back pockets. Nobody ever suspected a thing.
I don’t know where I picked up these techniques, but thievery came quite naturally to me. When you grow up with so little—a barren refrigerator, threadbare pillowcases—it feels almost obscene to be surrounded by such flashy excess. How could I not at least trace my sticky fingers over all those glossy surfaces? It certainly helped that I was the shy transfer girl who was (and still is) small for her age. I flew under all the teachers’ radars. They had their hands full with the campus bully who threw pencils at everyone or that smelly boy who bit other kids.
Before my parents came home from work, I arranged my spoils on my bed to admire. Finally, I felt the thrill my classmates did. But mine felt hollow; no one else to witness it except a slumping teddy bear. Alone in my room, the books and pens lost their sheen. The glee faded fast.
At recess, I was surprised to find myself still holding back from joining the spirited chatter about Ella Enchanted, only imagining my responses. Deep down I knew my copy had been ill-gotten, so any claim I had to the conversation would also be illegitimate. I became paranoid that my stink of social desperation would out me as the class thief. My book was tainted, so I was tainted. Unlike everybody else, I hadn’t purchased it, gotten it the “right” way. I had snuck through the back door of the club while others just walked past the velvet rope. Bold as I was, I could rationalize stealing, but what I couldn’t outrun was shame.
The hysteria of the Scholastic Book Fair died down. All that frenetic energy found a new container in the upcoming Spring recital and which songs the second grade class would sing. It turned out, having the fancy status book did not magically make me a fancy status person. Especially not when fleeting cultural moments come and go, and I had no other leg to stand on. While my stolen goods hadn’t fast-tracked me into social relevance, the kernel of guilt I carried meant I did have a moral compass after all. I wish I could say that realization set me straight. But the truth was, it took years for the desire to assimilate to wear off. I even got busted shoplifting twice as an angsty teen before I even began to grasp what self-acceptance meant.
Now, as a law-abiding adult who often drives below the speed limit and can afford as many books as I want (even hardcovers!), I understand that exclusivity is bought, but true belonging is not. Though if I tried to tell that to eight-year-old me, she would’ve eyed me suspiciously from beneath her jagged bangs. But I would reassure her. Because I’ve also lived long enough to discover that everything she so vehemently rejected—reading tattered old books, speaking a foreign language, and wearing secondhand clothes—has since become quite trendy. Even asymmetrical haircuts.

Jamie Li
Jamie Li is a San Diego-based writer with an MFA from Vermont College of Fine Arts. Her work appears in Tupelo Quarterly, Cleaver Magazine, Slant’d, and elsewhere. She is a 2024 VONA/Voices alum and a 2025-2026 Seattle Public Library Writers’ Room Fellow. She is at work on her first novel.