Review: Wrong Feast by Rivka Clifton
Reviewed by Sarah Brockhaus

Baobab Press, 2026
Rivka Clifton’s haunting and surreal sophomore collection, Wrong Feast, is interested in the complication of identity in process: of human, of animal, of object. In the world Wrong Feast builds, one thing is always another, and nothing escapes the reaching hand of capitalism. This theme is introduced in the first poem of the collection, “Consumption” which ends: “I wondered / how to detangle cash and flesh” (3). In this poem, the speaker guts a fish in a parking lot, an image that returns later in the collection, and finds dollars beside the organs. The catfish has both consumed the cash and will, presumably, be consumed itself. Here, the doubleness that forms Clifton’s mode of operation in this collection begins and the tension of the title is made real in the flesh of the fish.
The entire collection plays with and distorts reality through dream sequences, disorientation, and surrealism. Nothing is as it seems. The second poem, “The Master in Pieces” sets up the reader for the series of transformations and revelations that will unfold and unfold again in each poem; “A dog ran through the park. He was not a dog but a man in a dog / mask.” The poem is revealed to the reader through multiple disorientations: the dog becomes not a dog but the concerning idea of a man in a dog mask, before the line turns and we understand the image wholly. This first, false image of the dog in the park is essential to the transformation the speaker brings us along for throughout the collection. We see the change as it happens, rather than only the result.
The elusive “I” of Wrong Feast sneaks in through the façade of narrative throughout the collection. In “Cormorant” the speaker says, “My mother told this story / about a trapped wolf. / Wolf, wolf, over and over, / so I retell it with a cormorant.” The poem proceeds to string out what it presents as a narrative, but is really a lyric event, created through the situation of the retold story. The “story” dissolves until the speaker is imagining meeting the now long-lost mother, who has morphed into a wolf. The poem becomes not a past story retold, but an ongoing transformation experienced each time the poem is read.
It is this constant multiplying throughout the collection that moves the poems into a lyric space where mother can be both mother and wolf, and where “a black plastic bag / wears the hideous skin / of a large bird” in the poem “As it Was.” This poem does not simply make the plastic bag appear like a large bird, but instead makes the image both at once. In the poem “The Palpitating Wing,” the speaker is simultaneously on stage and on the subway: “on the subway stairs, floodlight. At the top, a shadowed figure. I was its twin.” Every subject of these poems, including the speaker, is twinned in reflection and able to hold contradicting truths at once: “I put on the clothes of another person. Midnight. Noon. Morning. Midnight. / I thought I could not speak. I spoke. I could not speak.” In this moment, from the poem “The Sheet in the Dislocated Room,” time is destabilized and can be read as moving from one part of the day to another, or as each moment of time happening at once, forcing through the impossible in the same way the speaker does by speaking and being unable to speak at the same time.
The poem “The Wasted Pupil” approaches transformation formally through a movement from a singular “I” into a “we” and back again: “we tongued the bottles neck. We watched the grass roil / in the wind–paths gliding like tributaries.” The individual becomes part of the collective, and the lines between both the paths and the people blur even as the speaker becomes isolated, individual again: “I can’t tell which I took / because when I turn around they are so similar. Whose hands / were on the wheel of the car that drove us?” Clifton is adept at creating concrete images that blur when looked at up close, that allow time and memory to enact their distortion on the page, the real and surreal coexisting. The smart precision of language and image in these densely rich poems allows them to hold their often contradicting, tense realities.
This simultaneity is called out most explicitly in the final poem of the collection, which echoes Brigit Pegeen Kelly’s singing goat head in her poem “Song.” In “Without a Leash,” the disembodied head of the dog cries from the fence:
The dog
rested his paws there —
larger than a dog, or a man.
It was as if he were both
at once. Night creature,
strange hybrid — but not
the moon’s changeling,
not the alternation between
two. The two inhabiting
the same body,
Clifton moves the doubling of the entire collection towards wholeness in this final poem, where the hybridity remains, no longer a switching between two, but instead made whole, “the two inhabiting / the same body.” Clifton’s stunning and surreal poems have a unique capacity for holding hybridity whole, for allowing something to be both what it is and what it seems to be. This complication is never abandoned in the pursuit of wholeness.
Sarah Brockhaus is a PhD student at the University of North Texas and received her MFA from Louisiana State University. She is a co-editor of The Shore Poetry. Her poetry is published or forthcoming in The Missouri Review, The Greensboro Review, North American Review, and elsewhere.